Book vs. Movie: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes
As I said in my review of THE BALLAD OF SONGBIRDS AND SNAKES, I actually saw the movie before I read the book. I loved it so much that I decided to listen to the audiobook as soon as I was done with the one I was listening to at the time. And, so this is more of a Movie vs. Book post.
I saw THE BALLAD OF SONGBIRDS AND SNAKES in the theater with Corey, my friend Kami, and her daughter. As I watched the movie, I had no idea what to expect other than it being set in Panem and in The Hunger Games universe. It made the movie more suspenseful and exciting in a way.
I thought that Tom Blyth and Rachel Zegler were fantastic in their roles as Coriolanus and Lucy Gray Baird. I loved Peter Dinklage as Dean Highbottom, Viola Davis as Dr. Gaul, Hunter Schafer as Tigris, and Josh Andrés Rivera as Sejanus. I also thought Jason Schwartzman was a fantastic Lucky Flickerman. He definitely gave me vibes that he could be Caesar Flickerman’s (aka Stanley Tucci) dad.
As soon as I finished reading THE BALLAD OF SONGBIRDS AND SNAKES, I watched the movie a second time. During this second watch, I noticed all the little details that were left out of the movie. While I do think the details add to the story, I think the director, actors, and screenplay writer did a great job of including what was most important to the movie. I also think seeing it on screen, hearing / seeing the actors’ emotions within each of their roles added to the story and experience a lot.
Verdict
I bet you know the verdict before I even say it. The movie may not have everything and be a little different from the book, but the spirit of the story’s still the same. Most of the time books are way better than their movies, but in this instance, I think both the book and movie are equally as good.
Have you read THE BALLAD OF SONGBIRDS AND SNAKES? Have you seen the movie? Do you like the book or the movie better?
It is rare that they are equal but you’re realistic. A movie can never (nor should it) show everything that’s in the book. The film would be 5 hours long! The gift is to know what to include, what to allude to and what to get rid of.
To tell you the truth, I’d probably be fine watching a 5-hour movie if it showed all that I loved about a book, lol. But, I’m glad The Hunger Games film people have done a good job with the adaptations. They definitely make watching the movies more fun. 😀
I read the book more than a year before the movie came out, so I’d forgotten a lot of details by the time I watched the movie. I enjoyed them both individually, but maybe one day I’ll read the book and watch the movie back to back. I’m glad you enjoyed them both too!
They are both good mediums from the story. I finished listening to CATCHING FIRE last night and I’d forgotten how much of the details were left out of the movie. It was fun to reacquaint myself with them, lol.
I have only seen the movie, but liked it. So I’m glad to hear they did a pretty good job with it compared to the book! Thanks for sharing your thoughts on this!
https://lisalovesliterature.bookblog.io/2024/02/08/review-the-reason-i-married-him-by-meghan-quinn/
No problem. If you do read the book, I hope you like it. 😀
I haven’t watched the movie yet, but I’m looking forward to it so glad to hear you thought it was on par with the book!
I hope you like the movie when you get a chance to watch it. 😀