
This month’s book was Precious Bane by Mary Webb. It’s a lesser known classic about a girl with a “hare-shotten lip” (cleft lip) and her struggle to fit in with society and deal with her greedy, ambitious brother around the time of the Napoleonic wars (at least that’s what I’ve surmised so far). I only made it to page 47 by the time we had our meeting last Thursday, although I’m a bit farther now.
Here are the thoughts from the group:
- Everyone really liked the book. Most gave it four or five stars. I’m not sure where my opinion sits just yet because I’m having a hard time getting into the story. To be honest, I’m a little worried that I’m not going to like it and be an outcast … kind of like how I’m feeling as I read Pride and Prejudice for the first time. I guess we’ll just have to wait until I’m done and see how I feel.
- Most had a hard time getting into the story. It took around 100 pages before they started to enjoy the book.
- Everyone really enjoyed the symbolism. They said it was done right and it was easy to see and understand.
- Everyone was fascinated with the idea of a Sin Eater because it was a very foreign concept. It was very strange to me, but very enlightening in regards to the superstitions and beliefs around the time of the Napoleonic wars.
- Everyone thought the raising of Venus was rather comical and brought a particular painting/image to mind that didn’t help the situation. (I haven’t got to that point yet, so I don’t know anything about it.)
- In my opinion, the language and phonetic spelling of some of the words make it kind of hard to read. But, I do like a few of the words because it reminds me of the Scottish/Irish English dialects.
- Everyone thought the “precious bane” was either Gideon’s greed and/or Prue’s disfigurement.
- Everyone thought this story is more a tragedy than a romance.
For next month, we’re reading About a Boy by Nick Hornby.




Title: 






